How-to: Reading a Foundry NDE Inspection Report

A foundry NDE report documents non-destructive testing results, defect locations, and acceptance decisions. This guide shows you how to verify that the quality control findings match the specified defect acceptance criteria before releasing production parts.
- Verify the part identification, material grade, and heat number before reading any defect findings.
- Map reported defect coordinates to the drawing or 3D model to confirm location.
- Check that the NDE method, operator, and acceptance criteria match the purchase specification.
- Review the final disposition to confirm the part is released, reworked, or rejected.
- Archive the report with the part number and lot number for traceability.
A foundry NDE inspection report is more than a stamped certificate. It is a technical record that links a specific casting to a specific test method, a specific defect location, and a specific acceptance decision. If you cannot read the report clearly, you cannot verify that the part actually meets the quality control requirements agreed in your purchase order.
This guide walks you through how to interpret a typical foundry NDE inspection report for investment castings. You will learn what to look for in the header, how to read the defect map, and how to confirm that the final disposition is supported by the recorded data.
1. Confirm the Part and Material Identity
Before you look at any defect findings, verify that the report is for the exact part you expect.
Check the following fields in the header section:
- Part number and revision.
- Material grade, such as A356.2 or AISI 4140.
- Heat number or batch number.
- Quantity or serial number of the part inspected.
The reason for this step is simple. A report for the wrong part is useless, and a report with the wrong material grade can hide a serious non-conformance. If the material listed is a different alloy than specified, the entire report is invalid for your quality control process.
If you are inspecting multiple lots, confirm that the heat number matches the material certificate for that batch. This is a common source of mix-ups when parts are produced in multiple heats during a single run.
2. Check the Test Method and Equipment
The NDE report must state the method used. Common methods for investment castings include liquid penetrant inspection, magnetic particle inspection, and radiographic inspection.
Look for the specific standard or procedure reference. You may see a reference to an ASTM method or an internal foundry procedure. You do not need to know the standard by heart, but you should confirm that the method is appropriate for the material and the defect type you are trying to detect.
The reason for this step is that each method detects different defect types. Liquid penetrant is best for surface defects. Magnetic particle is best for ferrous materials with surface or near-surface defects. Radiography is best for internal porosity and shrinkage.
If the report lists a method that does not match your specification, stop and ask for clarification. A report using only liquid penetrant is not a substitute for radiography if your drawing requires both.
3. Read the Defect Map and Coordinates
The core of the report is the defect map. This is a drawing or a 3D model view that shows where defects were found.
Look for the following:
- A clear scale or reference to the part drawing.
- Defect symbols or markers.
- Coordinates or reference points, such as “top face, 15 mm from the parting line.”
- A legend that explains each symbol.
The reason for this step is that a defect location without a reference point is meaningless. If the report says “defect found on face A,” but face A is not defined, you cannot verify the finding.
If the report uses a 3D model view, confirm that the view orientation matches the drawing. Top, bottom, front, and back can be easily confused if the part is asymmetric.
4. Interpret the Defect Description and Size
Each defect entry should describe the type, size, and location.
Typical defect descriptions for investment castings include:
- Shrinkage porosity.
- Gas porosity.
- Inclusion.
- Cold shut.
- Crater.
- Surface roughness.
The size is usually given as a diameter or a length, depending on the shape of the defect. For internal defects found by radiography, the size may be the apparent size on the film or the estimated size based on the film size.
The reason for this step is that you need to compare the recorded size to your acceptance criteria. A 2 mm porosity is acceptable on one drawing and rejected on another, depending on the criticality of the part.
If the report only lists a count, such as “10 porosity defects,” without individual sizes and locations, it is not a complete record. You should request a detailed list.
5. Compare Findings to Defect Acceptance Criteria
This is the most critical step in reading the report.
The report should state the acceptance criteria used. These criteria are usually based on your drawing, your specification, or a mutually agreed standard. They define:
- Maximum number of defects allowed.
- Maximum size of any single defect.
- Maximum size of a cluster of defects.
- Restrictions on defect location, such as “no defects within 10 mm of a machined surface.”
The reason for this step is that the foundry may find defects but still release the part if the findings fall within the agreed limits. You must confirm that the limits used are the ones you specified.
A common mistake is assuming that the foundry used a standard acceptance table. Many customers specify their own criteria because of safety, function, or downstream process requirements. If the report does not state the criteria, the report is incomplete.
6. Review the Operator and Witness Information
The report should include the name or designation of the NDE technician who performed the test.
Look for:
- Technician name or ID.
- Qualification level or certification reference.
- Date of inspection.
- Witness signature, if required by your specification.
The reason for this step is traceability. If a defect is later found in service, you need to be able to trace the inspection back to a qualified person. A report without an operator name is a weak record.
If the foundry uses an external NDE contractor, the report should also list the contractor name and the method used. This is common for high-value or safety-critical parts.
7. Check the Final Disposition and Release
The report must end with a clear disposition.
Typical dispositions include:
- Accept.
- Accept with notes.
- Reject.
- Rework and re-inspect.
- Hold for customer review.
The reason for this step is that a report without a disposition is just a list of findings. You need a formal decision.
If the disposition is “Accept,” confirm that the acceptance is based on the criteria stated in the report. If the disposition is “Reject,” confirm that the rejection is due to a specific defect that exceeds the criteria.
If the disposition is “Rework,” the report should state what rework is required. For example, “grind down the crater to 0.5 mm depth and re-inspect.” The rework should then be re-inspected and a new report issued.
8. Verify the Report Against Your Purchase Order
The final step is to compare the report to your purchase order and drawing.
Check the following:
- Part number and revision match.
- Material grade matches.
- NDE methods match the specified requirements.
- Defect acceptance criteria match the drawing or specification.
- Quantity inspected matches the lot size.
- Disposition matches your expected release.
The reason for this step is to catch discrepancies that can happen during the production process. A part may be produced to the wrong revision, or the NDE requirement may be missed.
If everything matches, you can release the part. If anything does not match, hold the part and contact the foundry for a clarification or a corrected report.
Common Mistakes When Reading an NDE Report
- Ignoring the material grade. A report for the wrong alloy is useless.
- Not checking the defect location. A defect size without a location is not actionable.
- Assuming standard criteria. Always verify the acceptance criteria used.
- Skipping the operator qualification. A report without a qualified operator is a weak traceability record.
- Accepting a report without a disposition. The report must state a decision.
Final Verification Step
After you have read the report, perform a final check.
Print the report or save a PDF copy. Place it next to the part drawing and the purchase order. Walk through the list of NDE methods required by the drawing. Confirm that each method appears in the report. Confirm that each defect finding is within the acceptance criteria. Confirm that the final disposition is “Accept” or “Accept with notes.”
If you pass this check, the part is ready for release. If you fail, hold the part and contact the foundry.
A clear NDE report is a quality control document, not just a certificate. It is the evidence that the part was tested, the defects were evaluated, and the decision was made based on agreed criteria. When you read it carefully, you are not just checking a box. You are verifying that the part you are receiving is the part you specified.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an NDE report and a material certificate?
A material certificate documents the chemistry and mechanical properties of the raw material. An NDE report documents the inspection results of the finished part. Both are needed for full traceability.
Can a foundry use a different NDE method than what I specified?
No. If your drawing or specification requires a specific method, the foundry must use that method. If they need to substitute a method, they should contact you for approval before proceeding.
What if the report lists a defect that I do not see?
Contact the foundry and ask for a photo or a more detailed description. For internal defects, you may request a radiograph or a CT scan to verify the finding. Do not release the part until the issue is resolved.
How long should I keep an NDE report?
Keep the report for the service life of the part or as required by your industry. For safety-critical parts, retention is often required for many years. Check your internal quality policy and any applicable regulations.
What does "NDE" stand for?
NDE stands for Non-Destructive Examination. It is a group of inspection methods that allow you to test a part without damaging it. Common NDE methods include liquid penetrant, magnetic particle, and radiographic inspection.


